Clinical Description
The clinical characteristics of Birt-Hogg-Dubé syndrome (BHDS) include fibrofolliculomas (specific cutaneous lesions), pulmonary cysts / history of pneumothorax, and various types of renal tumors. Intra- as well as interfamilial variation in disease severity can be significant. To date, more than 1,000 individuals have been identified with a pathogenic variant in FLCN. The following description of the phenotypic features associated with this condition is based on these reports.
Table 2.
Birt-Hogg-Dubé Syndrome: Frequency of Select Features
View in own window
Feature | % of Persons w/Feature (lifetime risk) | Comment |
---|
Cutaneous manifestations (e.g., fibrofolliculoma, acrochordons) | 87%-97% 1 | Cutaneous manifestations are unusual in persons age <20 yrs. |
Pulmonary cysts | 70%-85% 2 | The age when cysts start to appear is unknown; childhood onset is likely. |
Spontaneous recurrent pneumothorax | 24%-48% 3 | |
Renal cell carcinoma | 15%-30% 4, 5 | |
Cutaneous Manifestations
Individuals with BHDS usually present with multiple small skin-colored, opaque, whitish or yellowish dome-shaped papules known as fibrofolliculomas. These noncancerous skin lesions start to appear between the second and fourth decade of life. They are the most common cutaneous manifestation in individuals with BHDS by age 70 years. In early stages they are typically found centrofacially (nasal and paranasal) and in a retroauricular location. They often increase in size, number, and distribution with age, eventually involving the face, neck, and upper trunk. Later onset of cutaneous lesions tends to correlate with a milder skin phenotype. Women tend to have smaller and fewer lesions than men. The large variability in age of onset and expression often limits their usefulness for clinical diagnosis, especially in younger individuals. If present, however, they are a helpful indicator of BHDS. Histopathologically circumscribed fibrosis is seen, which, depending on the location, is described as: perifollicular fibroma, often replacing the entire hair follicle in the corium; as fibrofolliculoma, with elongated fingerlike extensions; or as trichodiscoma, located subepidermally, mostly parallel to the skin surface.
Note: Trichodiscomas, formerly described as tumors of the hair disc, are now considered to be scarred remnants of fibrofolliculomas [Tellechea et al 2015].
Additional benign adnexal tumors have been described as achrocordons (skin tags) [Toro et al 2008]. Achrocordons are also common skin lesions found in 25% of the general population and are more common in individuals with obesity and/or advanced age. Achrocordons are typically located on the neck, axillae, and larger skin folds. Angiofibromas have also been reported in individuals with BHDS but are more common in individuals with tuberous sclerosis. Individuals with BHDS may also develop oral papules (located on the buccal mucosa, tongue, gums, or lips) and cutaneous collagenomas [Nadershahi et al 1997, Toro et al 1999]. Multiple epidermal cysts have been found in approximately 14% of individuals with BHDS [Kluger et al 2010].
BHDS has been reported to be associated with cutaneous melanoma, including multiple desmoplastic melanomas [Lindor et al 2001, Khoo et al 2002, Welsch et al 2005, Toro et al 2008, Cocciolone et al 2010, Sempau et al 2010, Mota-Burgos et al 2013, Sattler et al 2018a] and choroidal melanoma [Fontcuberta et al 2011]. In one study an overall rate of 6% was observed for melanoma, which would be significantly higher than the lifetime risk of melanoma in the general population of 1.8%-2.4%. Whether individuals with BHDS are indeed at increased risk of developing melanoma compared to the general population requires further investigation.
Pulmonary Cysts and Spontaneous Pneumothorax
Lung cysts, located mainly in the basal lung regions (subpleural and intrapulmonary areas), are common in adults with BHDS. The total number of lung cysts per individual ranges from zero to 166 (mean: 16). They are of irregular shape and variable size (1.0-30 mm). The cysts are usually embedded in normal parenchyma that does not exhibit signs of proliferation (as seen in tuberous sclerosis), inflammation (as seen in cystic fibrosis), or matrix deposition (as occurs in amyloidosis).
With an average age of onset of 30.2 years in females and 38.4 years in males, spontaneous pneumothorax is often the first manifestation in individuals with BHDS (onset range: age 13-69 years). In most individuals the risk of pneumothorax decreases in later adulthood. This could indicate that the formation of lung cysts is a process mainly restricted to younger individuals. Chest CT examination to screen for lung cysts is not feasible in healthy children from families with BHDS; thus, the age at which the lung cysts start to develop is unknown.
Renal Cysts and Tumors
Renal tumors associated with BHDS tend to be bilateral and multifocal, but isolated tumors are also common. The reported overall prevalence of renal tumors among individuals with a germline FLCN pathogenic variant varies between 19% and 35%. These differences may reflect ascertainment bias as well as the inclusion or exclusion of benign renal tumors. No sex differences are observed in the median age of diagnosis (females: 54.5 years, range 37-79 years; males: 57.0 years, range 30-80 years). The median age of onset is well below that of sporadic renal cell carcinoma (61.8 years) [Furuya et al 2016, Sattler et al 2018b]. Adolescent onset of renal cell carcinoma in individuals with BHDS has been reported [Schneider et al 2018].
The most typical renal tumor in BHDS is a hybrid of oncocytoma and chromophobe histologic cell types, the so-called oncocytic hybrid tumor or hybrid oncocytoma/chromophobe tumor. It has been previously described as the most common tumor type in BHDS, but this could be an ascertainment artifact. Other common renal tumor types are clear cell carcinoma and oncocytoma; papillary carcinoma is less common. Discordance of histologic subtypes in bilateral and multifocal tumors is common.
Multifocal renal oncocytosis, a rare pathologic condition characterized by numerous oncocytic nodules, is found in the renal parenchyma surrounding tumors in 50%-58% of individuals with BHDS [Kuroda et al 2014]. It is still unclear if renal oncocytosis represents a precursor lesion of renal cell carcinoma or a benign condition.
Other Findings
Parotid tumors. Parotid oncocytoma has been reported in several individuals with BHDS [Toro et al 2008, Yoshida et al 2018]. Additionally, pleomorphic adenoma [Palmirotta et al 2008] and Warthin parotid tumor [Maffé et al 2011] have been described. Bilateral parotid tumors have been reported in two individuals [Maffé et al 2011, Lindor et al 2012]. The frequency and the sometimes bilateral, multifocal nature of these tumors in individuals with BHDS who have not undergone specific screening for parotid tumors suggest that parotid tumors are a manifestation of BHDS.
Thyroid pathology. Several instances of thyroid cancer in individuals with BHDS have been reported [Toro et al 2008, Kunogi et al 2010, Benusiglio et al 2014a, Dong et al 2016, Pérez García et al 2017, Panagiotidis et al 2018]. Multinodular goiter [Drummond et al 2002, Welsch et al 2005], thyroid nodules, and/or cysts have also been reported. In a French series, thyroid nodules and/or cysts were detected by ultrasonography in 13/20 individuals (65%) with BHDS; no medullary carcinoma or other thyroid carcinomas were detected. None of the affected individuals with thyroid nodules and/or cysts had a familial history of thyroid cancer. Overall, individuals with thyroid nodules were found in nine of ten families (90%) with FLCN germline pathogenic variants [Kluger et al 2010].
Colon cancer.
Hornstein & Knickenberg [1975] described a family with fibrofolliculoma and colorectal polyps. Hornstein-Knickenberg syndrome is now believed to be identical to BHDS. Several instances of colon cancer or colon polyps have been described in affected individuals and family members [Kayhan et al 2017, Motegi et al 2018], but the evidence associating colonic neoplasm and BHDS is conflicting. It has been suggested that only certain pathogenic variants are associated with an increased risk for colon cancer, but other studies were not able to confirm this [Khoo et al 2002, Zbar et al 2002, Nahorski et al 2010] (see Genotype-Phenotype Correlations and Molecular Genetics). Early-onset colon cancer (age >50 years) might be more common in individuals with BHDS compared to the general population [Sattler et al 2021].
Other tumor types have been reported rarely in individuals with BHDS [Tong et al 2018]:
Skin. Basal cell carcinoma, dermatofibrosarcoma protuberans, Koenen tumor, squamous cell carcinoma, trichoblastoma
Soft tissue. Angiolipoma, leiomyoma, leiomyosarcoma, lipoma
Musculoskeletal. Cardiac rhabdomyoma, fibrosarcoma, osteoma, rhabdomyoma, sarcoma
Gastrointestinal. Gastric cancer, hepatic cysts, hepatic angioma, peritoneal mesothelioma
Head and neck. Parathyroid adenoma, squamous cell carcinoma, throat cancer
Endocrine. Adrenal adenoma, oncocytic adrenal tumor, pheochromocytoma
Hematologic/lymphatic. Hodgkin lymphoma, leukemia, and non-Hodgkin lymphoma
Nervous system. Astrocytoma, cerebral hemangioma, choroidal melanoma, meningioma, neurothekeoma, oncocytic pituitary adenoma, schwannoma
Lung. Adenocarcinoma, bronchoalveolar carcinoma, clear cell sugar tumor, histiocytoma
Renal/urinary tract. Neuroendocrine tumor, prostate cancer, renal angiomyolipoma
Reproductive system. Breast cancer including sarcoma, endometrial carcinoma, fibroadenomatosis, uterine cancer