Clinical Description
Spinocerebellar ataxia type 4 (SCA4) is a progressive neurologic disease characterized over time by cerebellar / brain stem involvement, sensory neuropathy, upper and lower motor neuron involvement, and autonomic dysfunction as well as less common signs and symptoms including weight loss.
To date, more than 200 affected individuals have been identified in families with SCA4. For many reports only historical information is available; however, several publications have provided information on modern genetic studies and more detailed clinical information on individuals and kindreds described previously [Flanigan et al 1996, Hellenbroich et al 2003, Maschke et al 2005, Hellenbroich et al 2006, Wictorin et al 2014]. Recently, clinical assessments on more than 50 individuals have been reported [Chen et al 2024, Dalski et al 2024, Figueroa et al 2024, Paucar et al 2024, Wallenius et al 2024a]. Among these reports, the extent of the assessments and descriptions of disease signs and symptoms differ. The following description of the phenotypic features of SCA4 is based on these reports.
Age of onset of initial manifestations of SCA4 reported to date ranges from 12 to 65 years. Compared to individuals with milder, later-onset disease, those with early-onset disease (i.e., before age 25 years) develop more severe and often different manifestations.
Cerebellar / Brain Stem Involvement
Balance and gait disturbances affect all individuals with SCA4 and are the most frequent presenting disease manifestations. The main and predominant cause is cerebellar dysfunction in most individuals; however, sensory ataxia may contribute early in the disease course, and in some it can be a prominent component. As the disease progresses, particularly in those with early-onset disease, upper and lower motor neuron involvement and orthostatic hypotension can further aggravate balance and gait problems. Most individuals eventually require a walker or wheelchair.
Cerebellar ataxia of the limbs develops in all individuals.
Eye movement abnormalities can cause difficulty in rapidly directing the gaze in different directions, causing the sensation of dizziness when walking. Over time, restriction of horizontal or vertical gaze or all eye movements may occur.
While the range of reported eye movement abnormalities is compatible with radiologic and neuropathologic evidence that the disease process affects both the cerebellum and the brain stem, it may also reflect differences in the assessment or reporting of neuro-ophthalmologic findings.
Dysarthria, occurring in most individuals over time, can be cerebellar type with imprecise articulation and scanning speech. Some individuals depend on augmentative and alternative means of communication (AAC).
Some individuals may have a predominantly nasal or hypernasal speech [A Puschmann, personal observation].
Dysphagia, affecting many individuals over time, often causes longer-than-usual times to eat a meal or an inability to eat sufficient meals, contributing to the marked involuntary weight loss observed in many persons. Some individuals need to depend on gastrostomy tube placement to assure adequate caloric intake.
Sensory Neuropathy
Paresthesias with tingling or burning sensations in the feet or hands are common, with a distal-to-proximal gradient; symptoms of restless legs also occur. Affected individuals may experience worsening of their balance and gait disturbances in darkness, as observed in sensory ataxia [Wallenius et al 2024a].
Neurophysiologic signs (a reduction in amplitude or complete loss of sensory nerve action potentials) may predate the onset of balance and gait impairment or other clinical manifestations [Wictorin et al 2014].
Upper Motor Neuron (UMN) and/or Lower Motor Neuron (LMN) Involvement
UMN involvement, observed in about 85% of individuals, includes extensor plantar reflex responses usually without foot clonus or spasticity.
Later in the disease course, LMN involvement, including weakness and muscle wasting that occurs in 30%-100% of individuals, may contribute to difficulties standing and walking [Maschke et al 2005, Wictorin et al 2014]. Fasciculations have been reported.
Autonomic Dysfunction
In individuals with earlier-onset disease or in advanced disease stages, autonomic dysfunction can become very disabling.
Orthostatic hypotension of variable degree affects most persons during their disease and is often symptomatic.
In individuals with more severe disease, orthostatic hypotension can become so pronounced that in extreme cases, individuals cannot be erect or even in a sitting position (despite intensive pharmacologic treatment) because marked drops in blood pressure cause fainting [Wictorin et al 2014, Wallenius et al 2024a].
In individuals with later-onset disease, orthostatic hypotension may remain subclinical and may not cause impairment because affected individuals tend to start using a wheelchair when their gait and balance problems occur, thus avoiding the frequent postural changes that occur in individuals who are ambulatory.
Other manifestations of autonomic dysfunction can include the following:
Neurogenic urinary bladder disturbances often lead to urinary incontinence.
Increased bowel movements may cause diarrhea; decreased bowel movements may cause constipation. Both can be either mild or severe. When severe either can cause significant distress.
Erectile dysfunction has been reported; the authors suspect that similar dysfunction occurs in females.
Abnormal sweating or hot flashes may either be an independent phenomenon or due to decreases in blood pressure.
Sleep disturbances and acrocyanosis have been reported in some.
Cardiac arrhythmias, a cause of death in severely affected individuals, may be related to cardiac autonomic denervation.
Other Findings
Unintended weight loss. With disease progression many individuals develop unintended, marked weight loss likely caused by a combination of underlying disease processes (e.g., dysphagia, muscle wasting due to LMN disease, immobility, diarrhea, or possible changes in appetite) or mild behavioral or cognitive changes that possibly make some individuals opt against gastrostomy tube placement despite considerable cachexia [Wictorin et al 2014; K Wictorin & A Puschmann, personal observations].
Fasciculations. Faciolingual and tongue fasciculations, myokymia, and twitching of facial muscles have been described [Maschke et al 2005, Chen et al 2024, Figueroa et al 2024, Paucar et al 2024], as well as involuntary overflow/dystonic oromandibular movements when persons with very slow ocular saccades direct their gaze to the side [Wictorin et al 2014].
Movement disorders, observed in individuals with SCA4 but probably not yet fully characterized, include the following:
Dystonia manifesting as cervical or exercise-induced dystonia, foot or limb dystonia, or affecting the diaphragm, eyelids, or larynx (i.e., laryngospasm)
Mirror movements of the hands
Overflow movements in which ipsilateral facial grimacing accompanies attempts to lateral gaze
Tremor, choreatic movements, and myoclonic jerks
Parkinsonism has not been reported to date.
Learning difficulties and/or neurobehavioral/psychiatric manifestations. Most individuals do not show clinically relevant cognitive or behavioral abnormalities; however, exceptions such as the following have been observed:
The authors suspect these behaviors might indicate cognitive changes; however, this has not been studied in more detail. Nonetheless, these findings in some individuals suggest cognitive or neurobehavioral/psychiatric manifestations, perhaps within the cerebellar cognitive affective syndrome [Schmahmann & Sherman 1998].
Prognosis. Reduced life expectancy in individuals with earlier-onset severe SCA4 was associated with weight loss, infections, and cardiac arrhythmia. Life expectancy was normal or near normal in individuals with later-onset SCA4 [Paucar et al 2024, Wallenius et al 2024a].
Genotype-Phenotype Correlations
Genotype-phenotype correlations to date are preliminary as data are only available on 35 individuals with SCA4 whose repeat sizes have been studied by long-read sequencing [Chen et al 2024, Figueroa et al 2024, Paucar et al 2024, Wallenius et al 2024a, Wallenius et al 2024b] and 26 individuals studied with PCR fragment analysis [Dalski et al 2024].
Age of onset correlates inversely with the GGC repeat size; however, the correlation is not perfect, suggesting that unidentified additional genetic or non-genetic factors may also affect the age of onset.
The longest pathogenic repeat, 74 GGC repeats, was observed in an individual whose balance disturbances started at age 15 years.
The shortest pathogenic repeat, 44 GGC repeats, was observed in an individual whose disease onset was at age 60 years.
Larger GGC repeat sizes are associated with more severe disease manifestations, faster disease progression, poorer outcome, and shorter life expectancy. Exact cutoffs for large GGC repeat size causing severe manifestations has not been determined; however, it is likely that a gradual increase in disease severity is observed with increasing repeat sizes.
Some disease manifestations have only been observed in individuals with younger-onset disease who have longer repeat expansions, including very severe orthostatic hypotension that make erect or seated positions impossible, clinically relevant cognitive or behavioral changes that may remain mild or might include autism spectrum disorder [Wallenius et al 2024a], and reduced life expectancy.
Intergenerational Instability
Anticipation (earlier disease onset in successive generations) has been observed in many families; however, some children developed disease manifestations at a later age than their affected parents [Chen et al 2024, Dalski et al 2024, Figueroa et al 2024, Paucar et al 2024, Wallenius et al 2024a].
In five families for which individual-level data on age at onset was published, affected children developed manifestations of SCA4 one to 30 years earlier (mean: 10.1 years; standard deviation: 7.5 years) than their affected parents; two children developed manifestations seven and nine years later than their affected parent [Wallenius et al 2024a]. In other reports, affected children developed manifestations of SCA4 an average of 5.2 years [Flanigan et al 1996], 11 years [Dalski et al 2024, Paucar et al 2024], or 21.6 years earlier than their affected parents. Ascertainment or reporting biases may have affected these observations.
No difference in anticipation between maternal and paternal transmission was observed.
Increasing repeat length with parent-to-child transmission has been described in several instances [Dalski et al 2024, Figueroa et al 2024, Wallenius et al 2024b] and likely explains the tendency of the disease to manifest at a younger age in children of affected parents (anticipation). Future studies may be able to determine the degree of intergenerational instability more accurately (see Molecular Genetics).
Prevalence
To date, ZFHX3 repeat expansions have been described in more than 200 affected individuals from 26 families or kindreds [Chen et al 2024, Dalski et al 2024, Figueroa et al 2024, Paucar et al 2024, Wallenius et al 2024a]. While these studies included evaluation of several large and previously described pedigrees, at least 18 probands or smaller families were identified in a relatively short time after the disease-causing genetic variants became known.
To date, all reported families with ZFHX3 GGC repeat expansions have originated from Sweden (many from the limited geographic area of Skåne, the southernmost region of Sweden) or Germany (particularly northern Germany), suggesting a founder event [Chen et al 2024, Dalski et al 2024, Figueroa et al 2024, Wallenius et al 2024a]. Likely, the founder event is the (successive) loss of the non-GGC interruptions by spontaneous mutational events over many generations [Wallenius et al 2024a]. This is compatible with the inability to establish genealogical links between the families described despite intense attempts [A Puschmann, personal observations] and the fact that members in the oldest generations of several known pedigrees remained clinically unaffected.
No pathogenic ZFHX3 GGC repeats were found in 76 persons with undiagnosed ataxia from Brazil or in 258 persons with unexplained ataxia and 411 persons with multiple system atrophy from Hokkaido, Japan [Matsushima et al 2024, Novis et al 2024, Shirai et al 2024], indicating that SCA4 is rare in these populations.
To date, no pathogenic ZFHX3 GGC repeats have been identified in datasets of individuals with ataxia in other populations; however, information is lacking on the exact population background of these individuals.