Clinical Description
The clinical manifestations of primary carnitine deficiency (PCD) can vary widely with respect to age of onset, organ involvement, and severity. The broad clinical spectrum ranges from metabolic decompensation in infancy to cardiomyopathy in childhood, fatigability in adulthood, and absence of clinical manifestations. PCD has typically been associated with an infantile metabolic presentation that usually presents before age two years in about half of untreated affected individuals. The remaining half have a childhood myopathic presentation that typically presents between ages two and four years with dilated cardiomyopathy, hypotonia, muscle weakness, and elevated creatine kinase (CK). However, adults with PCD and mild or no manifestations are likely underdiagnosed, making it difficult to determine the relative proportion of these presentations [El-Hattab & Scaglia 2015, Longo et al 2016].
Table 3.
Primary Carnitine Deficiency: Select Features
View in own window
Feature | Infantile Early Diagnosis & Treatment | Untreated Symptomatic Individual |
---|
Infantile onset | Childhood onset | Adult onset |
---|
Typical age at presentation/onset
| Newborn | 3 mos-2 yrs | 2-4 yrs | Adulthood |
Metabolic decompensation 1
| Rare w/appropriate treatment | + | + | ± |
Hepatomegaly
| + | + | + |
Cardio(myo)pathy
| ± | + | ± |
Neurologic manifestations
| + | + | ± |
- 1.
Hypoketotic hypoglycemia, hyperammonemia, elevated liver enzymes
Infantile Early Diagnosis and Treatment
Infants diagnosed with newborn screening (NBS) and treated early are usually asymptomatic, as manifestations can be prevented by maintaining normal plasma carnitine levels.
Childhood Myopathic (Cardiac) Presentation
Skeletal myopathy. Myopathic manifestations include hypotonia, skeletal muscle weakness, and elevated serum CK.
Cardiomyopathy. Dilated cardiomyopathy is often present. PCD is associated with shortening of the QT interval and can result in arrhythmia [Lodewyckx et al 2023]. Death from cardiac failure can occur before the diagnosis is established, indicating that this presentation can be fatal if not treated.
Metabolic decompensations also occur in childhood-onset PCD, with hypotonia, weakness, hypoketotic hypoglycemia, hyperammonemia, increased liver transaminases, and increased CK.
Growth. Growth (linear growth, head circumference, and weight) can be negatively impacted if untreated.
Adulthood Presentation
Adults can present with life-threatening symptoms after being asymptomatic [Crefcoeur et al 2022]. Cardiac arrythmias and sudden death can occur. Cardiomyopathy in individuals with PCD responds poorly to standard therapy, and without accurate diagnosis and carnitine supplementation, it can be fatal. PCD can result in shortening of the QT interval, inducing severe arrhythmia [Lodewyckx et al 2023].
One study from the Faroe Islands estimated an odds ratio (OR) of 54.3 for the association between sudden death and untreated PCD [Rasmussen et al 2014]. This indicates the importance of screening at-risk individuals and adherence to treatment with levocarnitine supplementation to prevent the possibility of decompensation during intercurrent illness or stress or even sudden death.
Several women have been diagnosed with PCD after NBS identified low carnitine levels in their infants. About half of those women reported fatigability, whereas the other half were asymptomatic. One woman had dilated cardiomyopathy, and another had arrhythmias [Schimmenti et al 2007, El-Hattab et al 2010, Lee et al 2010].
Prevalence
PCD is very common in the Faroe Islands, where the reported prevalence is 1:300 [Rasmussen et al 2014]. The most prevalent pathogenic founder variant in this population is c.95A>G (p.Asn32Ser) (see Table 11).
NBS data estimated the incidence of PCD to be 1:348,333 in Australia and New Zealand, 1:121,609 in North America, 1:127,912 in Europe (excluding Denmark, Greenland, and the Faroe Islands) and 1:50,386 in Asia [Lefèvre et al 2023]. Some studies have suggested a higher prevalence in the Chinese population of 1:17,456 [Ji et al 2023].