Clinical Description
Mucopolysaccharidosis type I (MPS I), a progressive multisystem disorder with features ranging over a wide continuum, is considered the prototypic lysosomal storage disease. While affected individuals have traditionally been classified as having one of three MPS I syndromes (Hurler syndrome, Hurler-Scheie syndrome, or Scheie syndrome), no easily measurable biochemical differences have been identified [Muenzer 2004] and the clinical findings overlap; thus, affected individuals are best described as having either severe or attenuated MPS I, a distinction that influences therapeutic options. The greatest variability is observed in individuals with attenuated MPS I.
An accurate determination of the proportion of individuals with severe or attenuated MPS I has not been published. Data from the international MPS I Registry available in 2011 showed that of the 891 individuals included in the registry, 57% were classified as having Hurler syndrome, 23.5% as having Hurler-Scheie syndrome, and 10% as having Scheie syndrome; 8.6% were classified as either unknown or indeterminate. The potential ascertainment bias of registry data and the lack of a clear definition of phenotypic features for each of the subcategories should be considered in interpretation of the data [D'Aco et al 2012].
Table 2.
Mucopolysaccharidosis Type I: Comparison of Phenotypes by Select Features
View in own window
Feature | % of Persons w/Feature 1 |
---|
Severe MPS I | Attenuated MPS I |
---|
Course facial features | 100% | 10% |
Macrocephaly | 50% | 20% |
Hepatosplenomegaly | 100% | 80% |
Dysostosis multiplex | 100% | 100% |
Ophthalmologic issues | 100% | 100% |
Cardiac involvement | 100% | 100% |
Hearing loss | 100% | 50% |
Upper airway involvement | 100% | 80% |
Hydrocephalus | 25% | 5% |
Intellectual disability | 100% | 10% |
- 1.
The age of the affected individual considerably affects the phenotypic features.
Severe MPS I (Hurler Syndrome)
Severe MPS I is characterized by a chronic and progressive disease course involving multiple organs and tissues [Neufeld & Muenzer 2001, Muenzer et al 2009]. Infants with severe MPS I appear normal at birth but may have inguinal or umbilical hernias. The mean age of diagnosis for severe MPS I is approximately ten months; most affected children are diagnosed before age 18 months [Giugliani et al 2021]. In untreated individuals, death due to cardiorespiratory failure usually occurs within the first ten years of life.
Craniofacial and physical appearance. Coarsening of the facial features, caused by storage of glycosaminoglycans (GAGs) in the soft tissues of the orofacial region and facial bone dysostosis, becomes apparent within the first two years. Thickening of the alae nasi, lips, ear lobules, and tongue becomes progressively more evident. Thickening of the calvarium results in macrocephaly. Scaphocephaly is common. Facial and body hypertrichosis are often seen by age 24 months, at which time the scalp hair is coarse, straight, and thatch-like.
Hepatosplenomegaly. Protuberance of the abdomen caused by progressive hepatosplenomegaly is common. Although organ size may be massive, storage of GAGs in the liver and spleen does not lead to organ dysfunction.
Skeletal. Progressive skeletal dysplasia (dysostosis multiplex) involving all bones is seen in all individuals with severe MPS I. Children have significant early bone involvement. Mild dysostosis, particularly of the hip, as well as thickening of the ribs, can be detected on radiographs soon after birth but findings may be interpreted as within normal limits at this early age. Gibbus deformity (dorsolumbar kyphosis) often becomes clinically apparent within the first ten months; it has been reported as early as age six months [Mundada & D'Souza 2009].
MPS I registry data show that by age six months the median growth for individuals with severe MPS I begins to deviate from normal, falling below the third percentile of normal by age four years [Viskochil et al 2019]. Defective ossification centers of the vertebral bodies lead to flattened and beaked vertebrae and subsequent spinal deformity. Complications may include spinal nerve entrapment, acute spinal injury, and atlanto-occipital instability.
The clavicles are short, thickened, and irregular. Long bones are short with wide shafts; the knees are prone to valgus and varus deformities. Endochondral growth plates are thickened and disordered. Typically, the pelvis is poorly formed. The femoral heads are small and coxa valga is common. Involvement of the femoral heads and acetabula leads to progressive and debilitating hip deformity. Progressive arthropathy leading to severe joint deformity is universal; significant and functionally impactful joint stiffness is common by age two years.
Phalangeal dysostosis and synovial thickening lead to a characteristic claw hand deformity. Carpal tunnel syndrome and interphalangeal joint involvement commonly lead to poor hand function. Carpal tunnel syndrome is often missed because of its insidious onset; it often presents with few symptoms or signs other than thenar atrophy.
Ophthalmologic. Corneal clouding occurs in all individuals with MPS I. Progression can lead to severe visual impairment. Open-angle glaucoma may occur. Retinal degeneration resulting in decreased peripheral vision and night blindness is common. Blindness can result from a combination of retinal degeneration, optic nerve compression and atrophy, and cortical damage from hydrocephalus.
Cardiovascular. Cardiac involvement is seen in all individuals with severe MPS I. Cardiac involvement is evident by echocardiography much earlier than observed clinically. Progressive thickening and stiffening of the valve leaflets can lead to mitral and aortic regurgitation and stenosis, which may become hemodynamically significant in the later stages of disease. Mitral valve regurgitation is the more common valvular disease in individuals with severe MPS I [Neufeld & Muenzer 2001]. As lysosomal storage continues in the heart, cardiomyopathy, sudden death from arrhythmia, coronary artery disease, and cardiovascular collapse may occur. A small subset of individuals with severe MPS I have an early-onset fatal endocardiofibroelastosis.
Hearing loss. Hearing loss, which is common in severe MPS I, is correlated to the severity of somatic disease. Hearing loss results from frequent middle-ear infection, from eustachian tube dysfunction caused by storage of GAGs within the oropharynx, dysostosis of the ossicles of the middle ear, scarring of the tympanic membrane, and damage to the eighth nerve.
ENT (otolaryngologic). Chronic recurrent rhinitis and persistent copious nasal discharge without obvious infection are common. Storage of GAGs within the oropharynx with associated enlargement of the tonsils and adenoids can contribute to upper airway complications, along with narrowed trachea, thickened vocal cords, redundant tissue in the upper airway, and an enlarged tongue. This upper airway involvement leads to noisy breathing (particularly at night) and a deep and gravelly voice, and is a main component of obstructive sleep apnea, a common complication of MPS I. CNS involvement can also contribute to sleep apnea.
Gastrointestinal system. Inguinal hernias should be repaired surgically with the expectation that they may recur. Umbilical hernias are generally not treated unless they are exceedingly large.
For unknown reasons, many children with severe MPS I periodically experience loose stools and diarrhea, sometimes alternating with periods of severe constipation. These problems may or may not diminish with age; they are exacerbated by muscle weakness and physical inactivity, as well as antibiotic use for other medical complications.
Hydrocephaly. Communicating high-pressure hydrocephalus is common in individuals with severe MPS I. Impaired resorption of cerebrospinal fluid causes an increase in intracranial pressure, leading to brain compression. Increase in intracranial pressure can cause rapid cognitive decline in some individuals. Symptoms may be difficult to assess and progression insidious. The degree to which hydrocephalus contributes to the neurologic deterioration in children with severe MPS I is unknown.
Intellect. Although early psychomotor development may be normal, developmental delay is usually obvious by age 18 months. A measurable decrease in intellectual capacity occurs monthly thereafter (as graded by the Bayley Mental Development Index) [Shapiro et al 2018]. Subsequently, most children do not progress developmentally but plateau for a number of years, followed by a slow decline in intellectual capabilities. By the time of death at age eight to ten years, most children are severely intellectually disabled.
Children with severe MPS I develop only limited language skills, likely related to the triad of developmental delay, chronic hearing loss, and enlarged tongue.
In contrast to MPS II and MPS III, the severe developmental effects in children with MPS I are associated with placid rather than aggressive behavior. Seizures appear to be uncommon even at the end stages of disease.
Pathophysiology. The metabolic and physiologic bases of the various symptoms in MPS I are complex and involve the direct cellular effect of lysosomal storage of GAGs, inflammatory pathway activation, alteration of extracellular matrix composition and function, interference of other lysosomal and endosomal pathways, cell signaling, and alteration of autophagy.
Attenuated MPS I (Hurler-Scheie Syndrome / Scheie Syndrome)
If development is normal by age 24 months and if moderate somatic involvement is evident (e.g., mild hepatomegaly, relatively normal joint range of motion, mild dysostosis on skeletal radiographs, mild corneal clouding), an individual should be classified as having attenuated MPS I.
Onset of disease in children with attenuated MPS I is variable, usually occurring between ages three and ten years, but recognition of the diagnosis may be delayed [Giugliani et al 2021].
Craniofacial and physical appearance. The physical appearance of individuals with attenuated MPS I varies. Coarseness of facial features is less obvious than in individuals with severe MPS I. Findings can include a short neck, wide mouth, and square jaw.
Children with attenuated MPS I have variable growth restriction that may not be apparent until later childhood [Viskochil et al 2019].
Hepatosplenomegaly is variable in individuals with attenuated MPS I.
Skeletal. Skeletal and joint manifestations are the most significant source of disability and discomfort for individuals with attenuated disease, who may have severe bone involvement but no cognitive impairment [Vijay & Wraith 2005]. The MPS I Registry showed that more than 85% of persons with attenuated MPS I have dysostosis, primarily in the vertebrae and femur [Thomas et al 2010]. Kyphosis, scoliosis, and severe back pain are common. Spondylolisthesis of the lower spine leading to spinal cord compression can occur.
Progressive arthropathy affecting all joints and eventually leading to loss of or severe restriction in range of motion is universal. Carpal tunnel syndrome was present at a median age of nine years 11 months in 138 individuals with attenuated MPS I included in the MPS I Registry [Viskochil et al 2017]. Poor hand function resulting from the characteristic claw hand deformity, carpal tunnel syndrome, and interphalangeal joint stiffness is often observed. Most individuals do not have the characteristic early symptoms of carpal tunnel syndrome (see Management).
Ophthalmologic. Corneal clouding, exhibited by approximately 82% of children with attenuated MPS I, was identified at a median age of 9.1 years [Thomas et al 2010]. Corneal clouding can lead to significant visual disability. Glaucoma, retinal degeneration, and optic atrophy can occur.
Cardiovascular. Significant cardiac involvement is estimated to occur in approximately 88% of children with attenuated MPS I at a median age of 11.7 years [Thomas et al 2010]. Virtually all individuals with MPS I will have evidence of cardiac valvular thickening. Cardiac involvement can present as progressive disease of the mitral and aortic valves with regurgitation and/or stenosis, for which valve replacement may be necessary. Aortic valvular disease is more likely to occur in children with attenuated MPS I than in those with severe MPS I [Neufeld & Muenzer 2001]; however, in some individuals, all valves are affected. In a group of 78 persons with attenuated MPS I, 40% had involvement of one valve and 60% had involvement of two or more valves [Thomas et al 2010].
Coronary disease may also be a feature of attenuated MPS I.
Hearing loss. Moderate-to-severe hearing loss develops in many individuals with attenuated MPS I, particularly children with significant somatic disease. Hearing impairment, most commonly in the high frequency range, is likely caused by a combination of eustachian tube dysfunction, dysostosis of the ossicles of the middle ear, and eighth nerve involvement.
ENT (otolaryngologic). Rhinorrhea is common. Sleep apnea as a result of obstructive airway disease and possibly central nervous system involvement occurs in individuals with attenuated MPS I.
Gastrointestinal system. Hernias were present in approximately 65% of persons with attenuated MPS I included in the MPS I Registry [Thomas et al 2010]. Many have also had inguinal hernias during infancy, often requiring repeated surgical correction.
Respiratory system. Progressive pulmonary disease may manifest as abnormalities of forced vital capacity. Respiratory complications (and cardiac involvement) are among the leading causes of premature death.
Hydrocephaly. The risk of communicating hydrocephalus and its complications are lower in attenuated MPS I than severe MPS I. However, hydrocephalus may occur with insidious onset.
Other neurologic findings. Arachnoid cysts may develop. The predictive power of changes noted on MRI does not appear to be significant in individuals with attenuated MPS I [Neufeld & Muenzer 2001, Valayannopoulos et al 2010].
Progressive compression of the spinal cord with resulting cervical myelopathy caused by thickening of the dura (hypertrophic pachymeningitis cericalis) is common in individuals with attenuated MPS I. Cervical myelopathy may present initially as reduced activity or exercise intolerance and may not be recognized until the injury is irreversible.
Intellect. Although development may be normal in early childhood, children and adults with attenuated MPS I may have detectable learning disabilities. No correlation between the degree of multiorgan disease and intellectual deficits in attenuated MPS I has been observed [Shapiro et al 2015]. If intellectual abilities decline, the course is more protracted than in individuals with severe disease.
Prognosis. The rate of disease progression can range from serious life-threatening complications leading to death in the second to third decade, to a normal life span (albeit with significant disease morbidity).